We’ve long heard that the ways the web is tailored for each user—how we search, what we’re shown, who we read and follow— reinforces walls between us. Veronica Belmont investigates how social media can create, and can break, our filter bubbles. Link to the podcast: Social Bubble Bath
Quotes
“Everyone looked like me. Everyone thought pretty much like I thought, so, it was comfortable, you know.”—B.J. May
“When I think about us in Ferguson, if it were not for us like coming together, using social media as our own space, we wouldn’t have ever begun the protest.”—-DeRay Mckesson
“It’s really strange sometimes to look back at old videos of myself or current videos of my family and because, of course, there’s a part of my brain that knows exactly what they’re saying and where they’re coming from and why they think the way that they do. ” —–Megan Phelps-Roper
She was born into Westboro Baptist Church and lived in that social bubble for a long time. However, as she reached out online, she started to understand others and started to question her own belief. Then she left the church. This quote is interesting to me because I have this feeling too when I look back at my ideology in different stage of my life, and at my friends in China.
“The average online user who does not use social media, use somewhere in between one or two different sources of online news per week, whereas those who use social media are exposed to significantly more different sources of online news……In some ways, the very technologies that some people feared would lead us to filter bubbles, right now, at least as they have operated in recent years, seem in fact to have the opposite consequences.” —–Rasmus Kleis Nielsen
His team surveyed 70,000 people from 36 countries.
How the episode used the conventions, and to what effect?
This episode followed the convention. It contains all the parts and has a very good structure. It’s pre-intro bumper has a nice background music, and quotes from people about their opinion on social bubble. This part sounds nice, and light on information, make audience interested in the topic. The standard intro is very brief, kind of acts like a transition between the introduction and the detailed content. The chunked segments contains 4 separate stories, presented in the form of interviewing. These stories provide real life story about social bubble can have different effects in different situations. The episode also has a standard outro at the end. Except there’s a joke at the very end to relax down the audience after discussing about social bubble.
What about this episode helps you pick the challenge to try out?
Social bubble can be easily broke by connect with someone outside of your normal social circle. One man in the episode unfollowed everyone on his twitter account, and then follow someone who has completely different opinion and experience. He was very happy to be able to see both sides by doing that. There’s one challenge similar to this, “Change up your media diet and watch one video from one of these Youtubers every day”. However, I don’t think that’s what I need. In real life, everyone’s ideas are so conflicting: school VS parents, friends in international school VS friends in China. So conflicting that I can’t even form my opinion. I really need a social bubble online. I need that group of people to let me know that I’m not alone. I need to rest in those bubbles, to see people can actually think the same and do the same. However, this challenge only ask to watch video, doesn’t say I can’t do what I am originally doing, so this is still okay for me.
What new questions do you have as the result of thinking about this episode?
- People form social bubbles because they are naturally similar to some people and different than the others; or is this people live in a bubble, which makes them similar to some people and different that the others?
- When you try to break a bubble and live outside the social bubble, how do you make sure that you are not swapping one bubble for another? Is social bubble just unavoidable as long as we are social?