The concept film genre is one that I personally have found to be fairly interesting; it is an interesting application of the short film format, with an element which bears a resemblance to a movie trailer. Giving an exposition of the plot possibilities that can be derived from the introduction of the context and setting, concept films also feature a particular visual style that constructs a certain mood.
The concept films I saw – “Alive in Joburg” and “The Kid” – were not entirely dissimilar in the sense of genre and mood: both films had a salient dystopic aura, albeit in different forms.
“Alive in Joburg” is set in Johannesburg in South Africa, as the title suggests (“Joburg: is a colloquial version of “Johannesburg”). Set in 1990, Johannesburg is shown to host extraterrestrial beings, who were initially accepted with a certain geniality, as the locals were beguiled by an extraordinary species that wore special “bio-suits”. However, the relationship between the locals and the aliens soon deteriorated, with the aliens having to steal in order to survive. Frequent clashes with the police ensued, while the locals can be seen with firearms to prevent the thievery of the aliens, resulting in heightened tensions. The aliens can be seen living in shanty and derelict circumstances, lacking access to necessities such as water and electricity. The film’s budget is evidently low, as majority of the shots seem to be taken in an amateur manner that is entirely uncharacteristic of a commercial, studio produced film. This concept film intrigued me, due to the fact that the locals who were featured did not explicitly mention extraterrestrial beings, and the statements they offered seemed broad and generic, almost intentionally avoiding the mention of aliens. Upon further research, I was unsurprised when I found out. that most of the film was not shot by the filmmakers; rather, all of the scenes featuring locals were in fact authentic interviews of South Africans expressing their views about Zimbabwean refugees.
“The Kid” by Dust presents an equally intriguing plot, albeit one that is concealed within a much more “tight” moment. A “kid” and a woman, clearly unrelated biologically, are running away from a group of assailants. The woman and child are finally cornered in an alleyway, where it is revealed that the assailants are only interested in the child. With an unyielding determination, the woman engages in hand to hand combat with the assailants, impressively subduing most of them. However one of the assailants shoots her in the head, and she dies. One of the assailants approaches the child whose palm is outstretched, the other one clasping the hand of his deceased protector. The child’s supernatural abilities are revealed, as he brings his companion back to life, seemingly by siphoning the life out of the assailant whose hand he holds.
Both of the films have a dystopic mood. While Johannesburg is shown to be littered with slums, and spaceships kilometres long are hovering above derelict skyscrapers, “The Kid” features decrepit alleyways, lined with sagging buildings whose walls are covered in confetti. However, “Alive in Joburg” presents a very explicit dystopian mood, as it is clear how the entirety of Johannesburg’s population, local or alien, is subject to decayed and ramshackle conditions, lacking access to water and electricity. On the other hand, “The Kid” presents a more subtle dystopic feel. One can observe skyscrapers and low lying buildings as found in several cities, with no apparent deterioration when viewed as a long shot, or as a birds-eye view. Instead, the grimness of the setting is hinted at in a subtle manner, when the viewer sees the underbelly of the city. Apart from the ominous flapping of pigeons amidst a quiet backdrop, and the unusually empty roads, a viewer might not be able to differentiate the setting from one that they may encounter in real life. This might perhaps not be fully intentional, and we must realise the limitations inherent in concept film that has a limited budget; the filmmakers could not transform an entire city according to their preferences for a setting.
Another similarity is that both films revolve around the relationship between two disparate parties. “Alive in
Joburg” explores the interactions between two dissimilar groups: South African locals, and extraterrestrial beings. Similarly, “The Kid” depicts the relationship between a young boy and a woman, estranged to each other by age and race. However, while “Alive in Joburg” aims to poignantly represent the plight of the extraterrestrial beings while depicting the inability of two different races to exist harmoniously, “The Kid” explores an undying and eternal bond of fierce loyalty between the two protagonists. Despite her knowledge that she was putting herself in danger’s grasp by protecting the child, the woman is adamant and unwavering in her resolve. The child feels a sense of loyalty even after the woman dies, bringing her back to life by using all of his strength and abilities. However, “Alive in Joburg” reveals how two disparate groups descended into violent clashes, representing the apathy of the locals, and the lawlessness of the aliens.
The cinematic styles of the two movies present a striking difference. “Alive in Joburg” has a low-budget quality, as it comprises of several documentary clips. As such, rather than relying on clever cinematography and dynamic action to fuel the plot, it relies more on a realistic depiction of the situation the characters find themselves in, exposing the hardships encountered in a more organic and unprofessional manner. However, a film studio that were to adopt this might choose to alter this unorthodox cinematic style into something more commercially appealing and mainstream, or choose to maintain the particular impact of this unique concept. On the other hand “The Kid” by Dust feels very much like a commercially produced, high budget commercial film. It features exciting action to fuel the plot progression, involving hand to hand combat. The fact that the woman is able to singlehandedly ward off several of the assailants involves the exaggerated heroism that is very typical of commercial action films. This film also features the usage of different camera angles, in order to create a a mood that is much more fast-paced and tense, than that of “Alive in Joburg”. “The Kid” features several camera angles, including the birds-eye view, the long shot, the tracking shot, close up, and medium close up. The combination of these in a rapidly and shifting manner affect the pacing of a movie in such a way that a more exciting, blockbuster quality emerges.