CAS Project Reflections

investigation, preparation, action, reflection, demonstration

Investigation
When I continued MUN in 11th grade, I wasn’t sure how our club could adjust to the new COVID-environment, all I knew was that I wanted to be involved. This is why I applied to join the MUN Executive team. With the MUN Exeuctive team, I investigated what the problems were facing our MUN club. In collaboration with the over mun club I helped coordinate communications and work to design a messaging and mun platform for our online conference

Action

As part of my MUN experience, I participated in a multitude of experiences. I was a part of the MUN Executive Team every week where we organized the club, conferences and completed miscellaneous activities. As a MUN trainer, I oversaw the training of advanced MUN students, designing a curriculum for them. As secretariat in the 2021 MUN@UWCEAST conference, I had to oversee the success the conference. In 2020, I participated as a delegate and chair in several conferences.

Reflection

My time in MUN has been extremely rewarding. I have been a part of this amazing MUN journey since the first year I was in UWC – 6th grade. In High School, I have loved being able to travel with my friends and participate in really interesting debates where I am able to sharpen my skills. For these last two years, I have had a great time having control over organizing conferences and running our MUN club. From starting as a beginner to now being on the leadership team of the entire club, this entire process has been very rewarding.

ELP: Pause and Reflect 2

Detailed para explaining our understanding of Euripides’s presentation of Jason’s character to an audience

Euripides portrays Jason in several different ways to the audience. Our initial introduction to Jason is through the eyes of the Nurse and Medea where the audience feels disgusted by his lack of care and betrayal of Medea and the children. However, as the play progresses Euripides uses Jason’s seemingly kind demeanor to push Jason’s narrative that he is not in the wrong. Arguments and evidence are given to why he is noble and a man of wisdom – choosing to bolster his family’s connections. The main role that Jason plays is to show men the tragedies that follow if they fall victim to lust and greed, forgetting their sacred vows.

ELP: Pause and Reflect

How do we decide in our own lives who belongs and who doesn’t? How do cliques operate?
We generally interact with people who have similar personalities and interests. Cliques can be exclusive which can cause rifts and conflicts within a larger social community

What potential violence is there in drawing lines between who belongs and who doesn’t?
People can feel excluded and annoyed as some groups can be really hard to break into.

More broadly, who constitutes “we”?

Although it’s hard for people to average out opinions and beliefs, when referring to “we”, we are speaking to what the rational human being would do, say or think. “We” references a broader idea or though that humans have.

How does this relate to home fire or the poetry of Langston Hughes?
Home Fire and the work of Langston Hughes both give anecdotes on how society often restricts those that are deemed “unnormal”

Challenging stereotypes

What is the traditional / stereotypical image of Muslim women that Fahmy seeks to challenge?
A stereotypical image of Muslim women is of one that is submissive, conservative and oppressed. Fahmy seeks to change this narrative
How does she challenge this traditional image and how does Fahmy use everyday life / the ordinary to challenge ideas about Muslim identity?
Her cartoons are different and consist of several examples of Muslim women being comfortable and open. Everyday life is displayed so that people are able to understand the everyday lives of Muslims and thus empathize with them more.
How does Fahmy use humor to challenge this image?
Presents her Muslim characters in all sorts of ways. Muslims are often stereotyped as conservative and serious, inserting humor helps change these narratives
In what ways could this inspire women? Is this just something that is inspiring to Muslim women or all women? Why?
Across the world women face stereotypes and oppression. Fahmy can also be using her work to empower women to be more open and loose in their everyday interactions. Her cartoons don’t just show a Muslim woman, but also a woman who happens to be Muslim, she doesn’t want to limit her message to just Muslim women.

Hijab

There are several implications from the banning of religious items of clothing or jewelry, especially in countries where secularism is treasured. For countries that cherish personal freedom the banning of religious items seems to be a direct contradiction to this idea. Additionally, there is also the question of where do we draw a red line, will wearing clothing such as a shirt displaying religious symbols constitute a crime? It is hard and frankly borderline tyrannical for a government to have a complete say on our dress code and accessories. I strongly believe that religious freedom is a basic human right that should not be infringed upon by any state. Though there is an argument to make to ban religions that incite violence, isolated incidents from extremists within Islam does not mean that the entire religion, where the majority of people are peace-loving people, should be banned. Undoubtedly, the removal of any religious symbols should never be allowed.

Isma’s Identity

How does this passage help the reader understand Isma’s identity?

This excerpt from Homefire allows the reader to better understand Isma’s identity and her internal struggle between balancing being a Muslim and a British citizen. The excerpt opens up by emphasizing the trauma that Isma faces, “the memory of the Heathrow interrogation still jangling her nerves”. She is not only anxious about how people view her as a Muslim but the government also, “she had been able to think only of surveillance satellites”. To emphasize this feeling, Shamsie uses sibilance to repeat words that start with the letter ‘s’. This paranoia is furthered when she states she will be living “without the encumbrance of a roommate”, emphasizing her lack of trust and independence. The allusion to the story of Icarus foreshadows the relationship between Karamat and Eammon. Shamsie helps the reader understand more about Isma’s identity by establishing her close relationship with her sister, “sent it to Aneeka”. Isma is currently at the cusp of great change within her life; the symbolism of the changing of seasons is synonymous with this monumental change in her life. This passage also gives clear insight into the role of Islam in Isma’s life. She wakes up everyday for her daily prayer which emphasises her faith, values and her identity as a Muslim. The pair of gloves is used as a metaphor to not only allude to her siblings, but acknowledge that she and her sister are on two separate tracks when deliberating on what to do with Parvaiz. Overall, this paragraph strongly emphasizes the values of Isma and her identity as a British Muslim.

Islamaphobia

What have you learned about Islamophobia and the Hijab? In what ways has it changed your earlier perceptions about Islam? UK racism and Ted Talk

In the last week us students have been opened to several perspectives about Islam from Muslims. This has been interesting as we have not only been exposed to viewpoints that are not often reported in the media, but we have also been able to intimately understand Islamophobia. By listening to the experience of several Muslims, I am more aware of the myriad ways that Islamophobia manifests and the history behind the hijab.

The initial video from the UK helped contextualize Islamophobia. For a non-muslim like myself it was not only helpful for these Muslims to give their personal experiences with Islamophobia, but also beneficial for them to give their opinions on what Islam means to them. As a person of faith, I have been inspired by the Muslim community’s perseverance to continue practicing their unique religion even with the threat of rampant racism.

I had always thought of the hijab as an essential part of Islam, the word was synonymous with Islam, subservience to God, and humility. From this TedTalk I not only learned that the Hijab is not explicitly mentioned anywhere in the Quran and how it is possible that imams and scholars have inserted this requirement to patronize women: this completely changed my view of the Hijab.

A Letter to My Nephew – James Baldwin

This short piece by James Baldwin portrays the struggles of America’s black community through the use of a father-son dynamic. Though Baldwin does not exactly use this technique, elements of a fatherly figure are given to the narrator to help exhibit greater clarity on themes such as black resistance and injustice. His view on these issues portrays Baldwin as a trailblazer for his time.

The text starts with “Dear James”. The use of a letter text type gives a personal feel to the message that Baldwin is conveying. This underscores how Baldwin is trying to connect with the wider African-american community. Under the guise of an uncle, Baldwin explores the father-son dynamic – prevalent in African-american culture – to again connect with the wider African-american community about tough issues. In his words to James, Baldwin expresses his memories where he sees “your [James’] face, which is also the face of your father and my [Baldwin’s] brother”. This is referenced to highlight the historical problems that blacks have faced and have not been solved for generations. Additionally, Baldwin uses this opportunity to explore wider themes in pop culture. On the second page Baldwin addresses America’s racist history, “this is the crime which I accuse my country…history will [never] forgive them”. Baldwin not only addresses this grim fact but introduces the underreported issue of the vilification of black males in American media and the control of the black population by the state.

Likewise, the text gives several perspectives on the issue at hand, using literary techniques to convey them. “You must survive (pg 3)” highlights the perilous predicament that many African-Americans are in. When a typical American hears this, it invokes horror at the fact that this is reality for many Americans. The controlling nature of the state is reinforced with the use of invasive verbs, “set you down”, “you have been told where you could go” to describe the country’s policies. Baldwin’s letter is also in the form of a second-person narrative, making us feel like a black experiencing injustice. Simultaneously, the text addresses sensitive issues present in the black community. On page four, Baldwin encourages James – and all young African Americans – to embrace their ‘blackness’, “There is no reason for you to try to become like white men”, addressing the whitewashing of black culture. Much like activists such as MLK, Baldwin preaches, “show[ing] love”, at a time of racial tensions in the 60s. Finally, Baldwin refers back to his view on white society’s control of blacks, commenting that whites are “trapped in history”, implying that a prominent sect of whites wish to continue the oppressive policies of their forefathers in fear of losing power. To show the resilience of the black community, Baldwin alludes to Homer to show the long, powerful history of blacks. Baldwin addresses heartfelt issues of the black community by directly communicating with his readers – a technique used by contemporary producers such as P&G to raise awareness about racial injustice.

The Finkelstein Five

In Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah’s piece, “The Finkelstein Five”, Adjei-Brenyah uses the perspective of a conflicted black man to highlight racial injustice in the United States. The use of a first person voice allows Adjei-Brenyah to directly connect these anecdotes with his intended audience: white people. This is achieved through the use of varying literary techniques, which will be elaborated upon below.

Adjei-Brenyah opens up his piece by contextualizing the conflict within a young black man. He uses a “blackness scale” that is referenced throughout the story as a symbol of the internal conflict that many African-Americans have with their own culture/heritage. This subconscious struggle is highlighted in the first page when Emmanuel, “it was impossible to get his [Emmanuel’s] blackness down”. The author uses this example as another reference to the white-washing of black culture, exemplifying how blacks try to ‘fit in’ society by conforming to ‘white’ standards. This train of thought also allows the readers to better understand the notion of racial profiling – a hard concept for non-blacks in American to grasp. To do this, African-american vernacular is used to give an authentic aura to the experience. Emmanuel’s backstory and personal experiences allow the audience to connect more with him, making them more disheartened when they read the implicit bias he faces. Parallelism is implemented throughout the text to highlight the difference in treatment by the justice system towards whites and non-whites. On page 5, the judge takes the side of George Wilson Dunn, “I’ll allow it”, while security guards regard Emmanuel with suspicion and “trail him”.

The author also uses the text to focus on the ideas of identity and representation by providing multiple perspectives. The verdict on the white man on page 3 underscores how tight-knit the black community is, “his father cursed. His mother punched honks”. This scene also exhibits how discrimination is shared by all minority communities, “friends of many different races…had gathered”. Within the black experience, the author presents an important dynamic in the black community: the father-son relationship. Emmanuel’s connection to his father links to how he attempts to subvert his inner blackness. However, after experiencing racism, this subversion capitulates. This culmination of personal experiences with racism and subtle racism directed towards blacks in media, “African diaspora (9)”, makes Emmanuel’s path to violence more plausible. The technique of switching between George’s perspective and Emmanuel’s life corresponds to the double standards of America’s justice system. George is shown to be calm and collected as he knows he will be protected, while Emmanuel feels paranoid because he knows of the system’s track record with African-Americans.

Adjei-Brenyah uses this story to connect to many themes of black culture. He expresses blacks’ internal struggle with their heritage and also their experiences with racism to draw greater attention for his readers. To conclude, racial injustice is clearly portrayed through the use of a dual perspective and recurring themes relating to black culture.