To what extent are our societal beliefs influenced by stereotypes?
Text’s chosen:
Literary: “The intoxicated” by Shirley Jackson
Non-literary: Donald Trump’s tweet
Throughout the literary text “The Intoxicated” by Shirley Jackson, the dialogue is utilized to portray how societal beliefs influence society’s perception of stereotypes as what is considered to be expected out of a certain group of people. For example, the host shook his head ruefully and said “kids nowadays” this shows how the host speaks condescendingly about people his daughter’s age due to the preconceived notions about how kids her age should act or are depicted to act due to the way teenagers are displayed to act. This occurs through the media as well as in daily life, minor implicit and explicit inputs all individually and collectively contribute to shaping people’s societal beliefs and their consequent perspective of society as a whole.
People often jump to hasty conclusions and make assumptions based on other evidence they have been exposed to prior, this aids the shaping of their mindset and consequent outlook on the world around them. This is evident when the drunk man says to the daughter of the host “It’s part of a stage you go through, like being boy-crazy.” This shows how he is drawing on his perception of stereotypes to generalize characteristics of a certain population, in this case, being “teenagers”. The way that he just assumes this to be a fact and an accurate representation of teenagers shows how external influences and societal norms have all contributed to impacting his perspective on how he views teenagers as a whole.
Furthermore, the drunk man is portrayed to contemplate saying “in my day, he thought of saying mockingly, girls thought of nothing but cocktails and necking.” This illustrates how socially accepted stereotypes and gender norms contribute to forming an outsider’s perspective on others and the world around them. The fact that he wanted to say it mockingly elicits the sense that his intentions were not positive as mocking in nature is not associated with positive connotations, hence it evokes the sense that stereotypes are contributing to his view on this matter as he automatically creates assumptions based upon stereotypes held by society regarding teenage girls. Both stereotypes and societal norms have a bi-directional relationship with one another due to the fact that their relationship can work in reverse order too and they are in a causal relationship in which one causes the other and it works either way. This shows how expected behavior and the image of teenage girls are of cocktails and necking due to what is considered to be normal for that population, through experiences, media, and reputation.
In the non-literary text which was Donald Trump’s tweet regarding Greta Thunberg, it becomes evident how the way he was potentially brought up and the environment that he has been exposed to have shaped his views whether it be politically or otherwise. Trump’s past experiences and values he has been surrounded by have aided the formation of his current mindset and consequent views. Societal beliefs have enabled the shaping of his identity and hence the stereotypes he assumes are accurate. This is portrayed through his use of specific diction. He described what Greta stands for to be “So ridiculous” the word ridiculous indicating something that is completely absurd altogether. The fact that this is how he perceives Greta’s views and actions show how his belief systems due to societal beliefs he is exposed to have created negative perceptions. Greta’s passion for the environment and her emphasis and call for action on the impending and very current climate change taking place with potentially imminent devastating impacts appears to be absurd in Trump’s perspective. He states that Greta should go and work on her anger management issues due to the fact that she holds a contradicting viewpoint to his and is very popular for her age.
Trump furthers his extreme perspective through the use of including stereotypes he says Greta should “go to a good old fashioned movie with a friend!” This very explicit use of stereotyping is present due to socially accepted norms as many perceive this activity to be that of a common activity teenagers participate in. This use of stereotyping is implicitly showing Trump’s obvious aversion to the fact that Greta is getting involved in matters she is too young to be involved with as he believes she should be at the movies instead because that is her place, according to society at least. The way in which Trump says this with so much conviction shows the extent to which he believes this to be true. This is depicted through the specific punctuation he utilizes for emphasis. At the end of his statement claiming that Greta would be better off seeing an old fashioned movie with her friend, he uses an exclamation mark placing emphasis upon his perception of what she should be doing predominantly due to the fact that she is a teenager and watching movies with friends is an action often associated with teenagers. However, given the context, this display of stereotyping has negative connotations as it is painting teenagers as a population in a negative light particularly targeted at Greta as she is evidently going against the stereotypical norms of teenage girls.
Furthermore, in the non-literary text which is Donald Trump’s tweet, he uses repetition to convey emphasis on certain words within his tweet, he says “Chill Greta, Chill!” The use of the word “chill” consecutively shows how Trump is again influenced by stereotypes and is treating her like a teenager with anger issues that should be going to the movies with her friends. The manner in which he says this is belittling in the sense that he is disregarding her actions and perspective primarily due to the fact that she is a teenage girl and that this is not her place according to the impact societal beliefs have on him. The way he makes her appear inferior to him and makes it seem like she needs to be put under control because she is apparently not “chill” and adhering to normative beliefs she is an unruly teenager; this subsequently makes her cause appear to be unimportant the way that Trump perceives it.
The literary text relates to the non-literary text in the sense that they both share attributes of how people in society gain preconceived notions about something based upon stereotypes built on the basis of societal norms. The literary text shows how a drunk man interacts with a teenage girl and how the basis of their conversation is based upon the drunk man viewing the girl through the lens of stereotypes formed by societal beliefs. The man’s preconceived notions about the girl due to generalizing her as part of a population of teenage girls consequently primes his mind prior to any further interaction with the girl as these stereotypes have caused clouding of judgment and have caused him to already have opinions about her before actually interacting with her. In his mind, she is just a teenage girl and should, therefore, act like every other typical teenage girl. Similarly in the non-literary text, a similar phenomenon is impacting Donald Trump’s view on Greta Thunberg as his societal beliefs are caused by the presence and use of stereotypes through which it criticizes Greta for not aligning to. In Trump’s perspective, Greta should be doing things that typical teenage girls do instead of meddling in issues that are not considered typical of teenage girls.