Stimulus:
In the opening monologue of Brown’s New York show, he says, “My story was that I had a secret, a big, dark secret I couldn’t possibly tell anyone. . . . I presumed that I was gay when I was fifteen, but I didn’t come out till I was thirty-one. Which is a very long time to be avoiding the subject of sex. No one must ever know. Which is silly, because when you do eventually come out you realize no one gives a fuck. Truly, nobody cares. Which is a little disappointing, something of an anticlimax. All the things about ourselves that we think are so terrible—to other people, it’s just a bit more information about us. We’d worry a lot less about what other people think of us if we realized how seldom they do.”
Brown actually came out a bit later—at the age of thirty-five to his friends and family, and publicly a year after. Since then, he has come to understand the toll of having kept that particular secret for so long. “Before coming out, you work—unconsciously, but you work—to sort of divert attention from those parts of yourself that you don’t want to expose,” he told me. “And even when all that’s sorted out it doesn’t take much to bring it all rushing back, particularly if you’re a magician, because you’re doing something fundamentally dishonest.”
In yesterday’s session (October 3, 2019), we had our first weekly discussion; the two paragraphs above were the stimulus. We agreed that Brown’s perspective was too narrow and relied too much on his own personal experience with his coming out. Naturally, there are some people who, when they come out, are surrounded by people who do not care. However, there are people who are surrounded by people who do care, and not always in a positive manner. There are people, especially teenagers, who have lost financial support from their parents by coming out; there are people who have been bullied, fired from their jobs, and even killed for trying to be true to themselves. Brown had a relatively safe coming out, which isn’t bad and is in fact great, but he applies his own experience to generalize about every LGBTQ+ member’s coming out experience.
Some of the members in Focus Equality shared their own coming out experiences. Some were positive and had their parents being accepting and supporting. Others had parents that while seemed apathetic or accepting, seemed to not believe that their child knew their actual sexuality, stating that as teenagers they don’t have enough experience to really know who they are attracted to. Additionally, while before could talk about sexuality freely, whenever the topic comes up, the atmosphere become awkward and the topic becomes hard to talk about. The latter reaction, I believe, has a large impact on LGBT people because they already had to face years of dealing with either internalized homophobia or doubt in their own sexuality and gender due to the hetero-normative and cisgender culture of the world; and having their own parents not believe them, people who should be believing in them, increases the doubt and shame.
The idea that by not coming out, you are being “fundamentally dishonest” is also something that we discussed. In a way, some people might feel dishonest, especially in a generation that says that we should all strive to be true to ourselves. And closeted people might find themselves blatantly lie to the people who they should be trusting, such as their parents or close friends. However, another opinion might be that LGBT people are forced to lie; they find themselves in an environment not safe for them to come out.
It’s important to discuss this topic because, especially as members of the LGBTQ+ community and a part of an accepting community like UWC, we become so comfortable in a bubble of safety and security in our sexuality and the support of the people around us that we forget or ignore that not everyone has the access to such experiences. We have to keep in mind that we all have different experiences when we discuss how things affect the LGBTQ+ community.
While I think it will be hard to make a global impact as we are only one small group in Singapore, I believe by discussing and planning to create a better environment with a more critical and open mindset, we can make a safer environment within UWC and influence people to take this acceptance with them when they graduate.